Dessert Menu

City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar

Indulge in Sweet Bliss at City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar

Prepare your taste buds for a journey through heavenly flavors at City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar in Huntsville, TX. Our dessert menu is a testament to our family's culinary legacy, featuring an array of mouthwatering treats that'll satisfy any sweet tooth. From our signature deep dish pies to delectable cakes and other confections, we've got something for everyone. Browse our full dessert menu and let your cravings guide you. For any questions or to place an order, don't hesitate to call or text us. Your next slice of happiness is just a decision away!

Deep Dish Fruit Pies

Deep Dish Fruit Pies

Apple
$4.75 / $29.00
Cherry
$4.75 / $39.00
Peach
$4.75 / $30.00

Deep Dish Cream Pies

Deep Dish Cream Pies

Chocolate Cream
$4.75 / $24.50
Coconut Cream
$4.75 / $24.50
Key Lime
$4.75 / $41.75
Mocha Espresso
$7.50 / $45.00

Deep Dish Cream Pies

Ice Cream

Add a Scoop of Ice Cream to your Cake or Pie
$1.50

Deep Dish Meringue Pies

Deep Dish Meringue Pies

Chocolate Meringue
$4.75 / $22.00
Coconut Meringue
$4.75 / $22.00
Lemon Meringue
$4.75 / $22.00

Other Deep Dish Pies

Other Deep Dish Pies

Buttermilk
$4.75 / $20.00
Pecan
$4.75 / $30.00
Vinegar Pecan
$4.75 / $30.00
Pumpkin
$4.75 / $18.25
Salted Chocolate Caramel Pecan
$6.75 / $53.25

Mini Pies

Mini Pies

Apple
$3.75
Cherry
$4.75
Peach
$3.75
Chocolate Cream
$3.75
Coconut Cream
$3.75
Key Lime
$4.50
Buttermilk
$3.00
Pecan
$3.75
Vinegar Pecan
$3.75
Pumpkin
$2.75
Salted Chocolate Caramel Pecan
$6.00

Cakes

Cakes

New York Style Cheese Cake

A classic delicious cheesecake. Try it with a topping such as chocolate, caramel, strawberry, or passion fruit (more available upon request)!

$6.75 / $87.25
Carrot Cake

You are in for a treat! A delicious, savory carrot cake under a rich cream frosting will have your mouth watering before your first bite!

$6.50 / $49.00
That Strawberry Cake

Like Strawberries? You’ll LOVE this! With Strawberry cake, fresh strawberries, and strawberry icing — ‘That Strawberry Cake’ is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth!

$6.50 / $49.00
Triple Berry Vanilla Cake

Three layers of vanilla bean cake, fresh strawberry, blueberry, and raspberry puree with mascarpone icing! Yum!

$7.50 / $66.00
Layered Chocolate Fudge Cake

Moist chocolate cake with molten chocolate between each layer, topped with a rich chocolate ganache.

$6.50 / $49.00
Pina Colada Cake

For all of the Pina Colada lovers out there! This cake combines the tropical flavors of fresh pineapple and coconut into your favorite dessert!

$7.50 / $66.00
Lemon Cake

This moist and tangy cake is bursting with fresh lemons, lemon juice, and lemon zest!

$6.50 / $49.00

Other Desserts

Other Desserts

Banana Pudding
$3.50 / $30.00